Promises, Promises (Yet Still No Results)

Premier Of Ontario Kathleen Wynne, announcing the dissolving of the legislature of Ontario and the next provincial election (image and link are property of the Toronto Sun and it's parent company)
Premier Of Ontario Kathleen Wynne, announcing the dissolving of the legislature of Ontario and the next provincial election (image and link are property of the Toronto Sun and it’s parent company)

I’m now starting my second week of couch surfing, but that does not mean I haven’t been following the news like I usually do. The planned provincial budget vote (for Ontario) has held my interest for the last three weeks, since it’s defeat means the fall of the government and a new election. What actually happened in the end was Premier Wynne asking the Lieutenant-Governor to dissolve the 40th legislature of Ontario because one of the parties (the NDP) was not willing to support her minority government in the upcoming vote. Nevertheless, we have a summer Ontario election to look forward to. Yes, that was your sarcasm detector exploding in a fiery blaze.

I’ll be 50 years old this June, so I’ve been through my share of elections and the campaign promises that come with it. With each passing year (and every broken promise), I become more cynical of what each party says they are going to do once elected.

Let’s take that last statement to the next (and blunt and frank) level: I am firmly convinced all the main parties have no clue how to turn Ontario’s economy around, particularly where job creation is concerned.

I’ve taken the opportunity to study each party’s election platform, in specific how to deal with the chronic unemployment problem that I and other job-seekers struggle with. Starting with the Liberal Party, there’s a promise not to raise corporate taxes and to reduce small business taxes. That’s wonderful, except for two things:

a) Corporate taxes are already too high, which is why corporations have resorted to outsourcing jobs overseas and using the Temporary Foreign Worker program to replace Canadian workers.

b) The Ontario budget that triggered the election in the first place mentioned the creation of a mandatory Ontario pension plan that everyone has to opt into if they currently do not have a company or private pension plan. That’s actually a tax that hits both the employee and his/her employer. That will force employers to hire less while adding more financial burden on those working at or under the poverty line.

The Progressive Conservative Party has an ambitious plank in their election platform that involves the creation of 1 million jobs for Ontarians. To begin with, while i know Ontario has a serious unemployment problem, I do not believe it is actually that high so that number alone lends doubt to the validity of that promise. In addition, there is a reference to creating more skilled workers to fit the demand for trade jobs in this province. How? Through government funded career retraining programs? They already exist! It’s called Second Career! The problem isn’t the absence of these programs, but the eligibility for access to these programs. I have twice applied for Second Career funding, having filled out those dreadful forms. It’s like taking a prostate exam but with a pen and paper. A lot of questions to answer, a lot of qualifications to meet. In both cases, I did not get approved. If Tim Hudak and the Progressive Conservative party want to help people be better trained in order to land a job, start loosening the requirements of existing career retraining programs.

The Ontario New Democratic Party’s platform mentions not only a mandatory Ontario pension plan (like the Liberal Party), it also will push for expanding the Canada Pension Plan, which means more deductions for both employees and businesses. In addition, they promise a push to increase the minimum wage and invest more money in health-care. On the latter, that money has to come from somewhere, and like then-Premier Dalton McGuinty and the Liberal government did in the past, the NDP will likely raise the OHIP (Ontario Health Insurance Plan) deduction on our paycheques. Will we see eye exams and other previously de-listed medical coverage return to OHIP coverage? No mention of that on their election platform page. The most telling part of the platform is while it has hinted at actions taken by the current Liberal government as scandalous (google ontario liberal scandals for a list of examples that could easily fill the parking lot of a Wal-Mart), Andrea Horwath and the NDP party were the king-makers for past  budget votes. They could have forced an earlier election yet chose to vote with the government and keep it afloat for another day. In other words, the NDP claims to be the defender of the taxpaper wallet, yet allowed a government to continue with decisions that no only had a profound negative impact of the economy of Ontario, it also supported scandalous actions taxpayers had to pay for (such as the gas plant being moved to favour the outcome of key candidates). Based on that record, would I really trust such a party to handle taxpayer-funded job-creation programs?

With all that said and done, my approach as both a voter and a job-seeker is to grill each party candidate in my riding (well, whatever riding I decide to vote in, since I am now of no fixed address) with the following questions (copied from my post on the comments section of the Toronto Sun web site):

* how much will each promise cost to implement and where will the money come from to pay for each?

* when will each initiative take effect? Ask for a date of completion. If the candidate starts waffling doublespeak, you know it’s not going to be a reality.

* ask who in the party is going to be responsible for making that platform plank happen. Get. A. Name.

* most important: who will bear responsibility if any or all of the promises are not implemented.

These questions are not unreasonable. After all, people currently working are tasked to answer those same questions asked by their immediate employer while working. As someone trying to re-enter the working world and also a believer that government serves the people (not the other way around), I feel I have a right to demand that any election promises made are worth more than the ink written on paper.

Thanks for reading!



2 thoughts on “Promises, Promises (Yet Still No Results)

  1. Sorry David, but I totally disagree with you on the corporate tax issue. If corporations want a decrease in their tax rate then they first need to hire more employees. Otherwise the tax cuts will just go to into their pockets. And before you hire a temporary foreign worker, first you must put the job on job sites, including Workopolis,, and with the Government sites. If people apply, then the company must hire them, not a temporary worker.

    1. Hi Toronto Streetcars.

      Thanks for your reply. I looked up the corporate tax rate (combined average) for each province in Canada and found that even though Ontario sits in the median, it is still considerably higher than Saskatchewan and Alberta. This explains not only the migration of individuals westward for employment, it also explains the stronger economies out west when compared to middle and eastern Canada.

      In addition, according to a CTV news story, many corporations claim they pay more than their fair share of taxes: 33.4% of profits go directly to taxes. This burden manifests itself in employee layoffs, a symptom (as stated in one of my David Needs A Job episodes) that manifests itself in the form of low staffing at service and checkout cashier counters.

      Do not, however, assume I am a corporate apologist and cheerleader. There is merit to your point that if companies get a tax credit, there must be an investment of the saving into employment hiring and subsequent expansion.

      On the subject of foreign workers being hired only after all exhaustive efforts were taken to fill vacant positions with Canadian-born talent, the explosive expose done by the CBC and the subsequent freeze of further TFW hiring clearly shows that’s not entirely the case. In fact, since the Canada / US free trade deal was put into effect, jobs have in fact gone out of Canada into the hands of foreign workers both overseas and at home. One only needs to call Rogers or Bell for service to be greeted by someone named George or Mary with an accent so thick it could break the teeth of a chainsaw.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s